![Olof Hallonsten. Photo](/sites/lusem.lu.se/files/styles/lu_personal_page_desktop/public/2024-04/OlofHallonsten.jpg.webp?itok=VEOO81XU)
Olof Hallonsten
Senior lecturer
![Olof Hallonsten. Photo](/sites/lusem.lu.se/files/styles/lu_personal_page_desktop/public/2024-04/OlofHallonsten.jpg.webp?itok=VEOO81XU)
Are evaluative bibliometrics neoliberal? A historical and theoretical problematization.
Author
Summary, in English
In this article, we problematize the notion that the continuously growing use of bibliometric evaluation can be effectively explained by ‘neoliberal’ ideology. A prerequisite for our analysis is an understanding of neoliberalism as both denoting a more limited set of concrete principles for the organization of society (the narrow interpretation) or as a hegemonic ideology (the broad interpretation). This conceptual framework, as well as brief history of evaluative bibliometrics, provides an analytical framing for our approach, in which four national research evaluation systems are compared: Norway, Russia, Sweden, and the United Kingdom. On basis of an analysis of the rationales for implementing these systems, as well as their specific design, we discuss the existence or non-existence of neoliberal motivations and rationales. Overall, we find that a relatively homogeneous academic landscape, with a high degree of centralization and government steering, appears to be a common feature for countries implementing national evaluation systems relying on bibliometrics. Such characteristics, we argue, may not be inductively understood as neoliberal but as indications of national states displaying strong political steering of its research system. Consequently, if used without further clarification, ‘neoliberalism’ is a concept too broad and diluted to be useful when analyzing the development of research evaluation and bibliometric measures in the past half a century.
Department/s
- Organizational Studies
- CIRCLE
Publishing year
2023
Language
English
Publication/Series
Social Science Information
Volume
61
Issue
4
Document type
Journal article
Publisher
SAGE Publications
Topic
- Business Administration
Status
Published
ISBN/ISSN/Other
- ISSN: 0539-0184